The Sharia Mirage
10 Myths Muslims Believe About Islamic Law — Busted with Their Own Sources
Sharia is often marketed as divine justice — flawless, merciful, and morally superior to all human law. Muslims are taught it's a complete legal system from God not made by men but revealed through the Prophet Muhammad.
But once you read what Sharia actually says — straight from the Qur’an, hadith, and classical legal scholars — the image falls apart fast.
It’s not a system of justice. It’s a primitive rulebook of domination that’s been falsely dressed up as divine mercy.
Here’s a myth-by-myth breakdown of what Muslims believe about Sharia — and what the sources really show.
🔟 Myth 1: “Sharia is just about private morality — like prayer and fasting.”
What they claim:
“Sharia is just a personal code of conduct. It’s about being spiritual — praying, giving charity, fasting in Ramadan, stuff like that.”
What the sources say:
Wrong. Sharia is a total legal-political system. It’s not limited to private piety. It covers:
Criminal Law — including:
Stoning adulterers (Muslim 1690a)
Amputating hands for theft (Qur’an 5:38)
Flogging for drinking (Abu Dawud 4483)
Apostasy & Blasphemy — both punishable by death (Bukhari 3017, Sunan Abu Dawud 4359)
Rules for war (jihad), land ownership, and taxation
Gender laws — guardianship, segregation, polygamy, veiling
Slavery — ownership, sexual access, inheritance
It even regulates how to conquer territories, how to treat non-Muslims, and what to do with prisoners.
👉 It’s not a spiritual guide. It’s a blueprint for religious dictatorship.
9️⃣ Myth 2: “There’s no compulsion in religion.” (Qur’an 2:256)
This verse is quoted everywhere — even on banners at interfaith events.
But here’s the context:
Surah 2:256 was revealed early in Muhammad’s career, when he was weak in Mecca.
Once he gained power in Medina, his message changed completely:
“Fight those who do not believe… until they pay the jizya and feel subdued” (Qur’an 9:29)
“Kill whoever changes his religion” (Bukhari 3017)
“Slay the idolaters wherever you find them” (Qur’an 9:5)
This is naskh (abrogation). Later verses override earlier ones — and Islamic law affirms it:
"The verse ‘There is no compulsion in religion’ is abrogated by the verse of fighting." — Tafsir Ibn Kathir
So while Islam might tolerate freedom at first, it turns to compulsion as soon as it gains power.
👉 The “peaceful Islam” is temporary. The coercive Islam is permanent.
8️⃣ Myth 3: “Islam gave women rights before the West.”
This one gets repeated endlessly — especially by Western converts.
Let’s break it down:
Inheritance: Women get half of what men do (Qur’an 4:11)
Legal testimony: A woman’s word is worth half a man’s in finance and courts (Qur’an 2:282)
Domestic violence: Men are told they may beat disobedient wives (Qur’an 4:34)
Marriage: Men can marry 4 women, women can only marry 1 man.
Sexual autonomy: Men can contract temporary marriage (mut’ah) for sexual pleasure. Women can’t.
Leadership: No female prophets, judges, imams — by consensus of classical scholars (Al-Qurtubi, Al-Ghazali).
This isn't protection. It's legal inferiority embedded in divine law.
And let’s not forget:
Muhammad married Aisha when she was 6, and consummated the marriage at age 9. (Bukhari 5133)
👉 That’s not progress. That’s codified inequality and exploitation.
7️⃣ Myth 4: “Sharia is the most just legal system ever created.”
Let’s compare:
Sharia law includes:
Stoning to death for consensual sex outside marriage
Amputating limbs for theft
Public floggings
Slavery
Legalized discrimination against non-Muslims
Child marriage justified by the Prophet’s own life
Modern legal systems — even flawed ones — have:
Equal rights regardless of religion or gender
No cruel or inhuman punishments
Legal protection from domestic abuse
No death penalty for speech or belief
Islamic law punishes victims (like rape victims who can't produce 4 witnesses) and protects tyrants (male guardians, rulers, clerics).
👉 By any modern moral standard, Sharia isn’t justice. It’s state-sponsored brutality.
6️⃣ Myth 5: “Sharia is misunderstood — it’s not really that bad.”
Muslims often say, “Sharia is just misunderstood. It’s misused by extremists.”
Here’s the problem:
The most brutal parts of Sharia aren’t misinterpretations. They’re direct commands from scripture and upheld by the greatest Islamic scholars:
Al-Ghazali
Al-Shafi’i
Ibn Taymiyyah
Ibn Kathir
Al-Nawawi
These aren’t fringe clerics. They’re the core of Islamic legal tradition.
And modern countries like Saudi Arabia, Iran, Afghanistan, and Pakistan are applying these laws — not distorting them.
👉 If everywhere Sharia is enforced looks like a human rights disaster… maybe it’s not being misapplied.
Maybe it’s being applied exactly as intended.
5️⃣ Myth 6: “Sharia only works if people choose it.”
False.
Historically, Sharia was spread through:
Military conquest
Forced conversion
Mass executions of apostates and blasphemers
Legal suppression of criticism
The Caliphate didn’t ask for votes. It conquered territory and imposed Sharia on everyone.
Even today, Sharia-based regimes enforce it through fear:
Apostates jailed or killed
Journalists silenced
Protesters whipped
Women forced into hijab or punished
👉 Sharia spreads by coercion, not consent.
4️⃣ Myth 7: “Islam abolished slavery.”
Total myth.
The Qur’an and hadith explicitly regulate and approve slavery:
Qur’an 4:3 — you may marry from “those your right hands possess”
Qur’an 23:5–6 — sex with female slaves is lawful
Muhammad owned, bought, sold, and gifted slaves
Female slaves were taken in war and used sexually
Even classical scholars defended slavery for over 1,000 years — without exception.
Islam only stopped practicing slavery under Western colonial pressure in the 19th–20th centuries.
👉 Islam didn’t end slavery. It institutionalized it.
3️⃣ Myth 8: “The Qur’an is a clear and complete book of law.”
Muslims say the Qur’an is “complete and perfect.” That it doesn’t need anything else.
But the Qur’an:
Doesn’t tell you how to pray (no step-by-step instructions)
Gives almost no legal detail on most punishments
Says “cover your adornments” but doesn’t define hijab
Mentions jihad, but leaves it vague
That’s why Islamic law had to be built from scratch using hadiths:
Many of which were written 200+ years after Muhammad
Full of contradictions, political bias, and fabricated chains of narration
👉 A divine book should not require centuries of patchwork commentary to function.
2️⃣ Myth 9: “Sharia only affects Muslims.”
Totally false.
Non-Muslims under Sharia live as dhimmis — second-class citizens:
Can’t build new churches
Can’t preach their religion publicly
Must pay the jizya tax — a financial penalty for not being Muslim
Can’t testify against Muslims in court
Receive less legal protection — even in cases of murder or rape
And Qur’an 9:29 explicitly commands Muslims to fight Christians and Jews until they submit.
👉 Sharia doesn’t leave non-Muslims alone. It subjugates them.
1️⃣ Myth 10: “Sharia is God’s mercy.”
Let’s be brutally honest.
Under Sharia:
Women are whipped for not wearing hijab
Christians can be executed for “insulting the Prophet”
Gays are stoned or thrown from rooftops
Apostates are hanged
Child marriage is legitimized — because Muhammad did it
If this is “mercy,” what would cruelty look like?
👉 Sharia isn’t compassionate. It’s violent religious authoritarianism.
🧨 Final Verdict: Sharia Isn’t Sacred. It’s Strategy.
Sharia law wasn’t revealed to liberate people.
It was created to control them.
It fossilizes tribal customs and 7th-century morality
It uses religion to silence dissent
It hides behind the language of God — while enforcing power for men, clerics, and rulers
Muslims defending Sharia are often defending something they’ve never studied in depth — or they assume it’s better because it’s “from God.”
But here’s the truth:
Sharia isn’t divine.
It’s a medieval legal weapon wrapped in religious language — and once you unwrap it, you find coercion, inequality, and fear.
No comments:
Post a Comment